Academy Analysis Group G: Which clubs produced the most players at World Cup 2018?

Academy Analysis Group G: Which clubs produced the most players at World Cup 2018?
Simon Winter
Simon Winter
June 7, 2018
Show Bio

Born in the south east of Ireland, Simon put his life-long love of football to good use when he started a successful independent blog in 2010. That opened up an alternative route to a career in journalism, and having had work published across a number of sites and publications, Simon joined the staff at Spotlight Sports Group in 2018.

(Feature Image Credit: By Iklanmaju1988 (i made on my own) [GFDL (http://www.gnu.org/copyleft/fdl.html) or CC BY-SA 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0)], via Wikimedia Commons)

In the latest entry in our Academy Analysis multi-part feature, we focus on Group G, where Belgium, England, Tunisia and Panama will battle it out for a place in the knock-out rounds of the World Cup. In our analysis, we will determine which clubs’ youth teams and academies are responsible for producing the most players in each squad.

Read the first parts of our series first using the links below:

Part1: Group A: Egypt, Russia, Saudi Arabia and Uruguay.

Part 2: Group B: Iran, Morocco, Portugal and Spain.

Part 3: Group C: Australia, Denmark, Peru and France.

Part 4: Group D: Argentina, Croatia, Iceland and Nigeria.

Part 5 Group E: Brazil, Costa Rica, Serbia and Switzerland

Part 6: Group F: Germany, Mexico, South Korea and Sweden

BELGIUM

Belgium World Cup 2018

(Name of player – Name of club that produced them)

Thibaut Courtois – Bilzen/Genk
Simon Mignolet – Sint-Truiden
Koen Casteels – KAC Betekom/Genk

Toby Alderweireld – Germinal Beerschot/Ajax
Vincent Kompany – Anderlecht
Jan Vertonghen – Germinal Beerschot/Ajax
Thomas Meunier – RUS Saint-Ode/Virton
Thomas Vermaelen – Germinal Ekeren/Ajax
Dedryck Boyata – Brussels/Man City

Alex Witsel – Standard Liege
Kevin De Bruyne – Gent/Genk
Marouane Fellaini – Anderlecht
Adnan Januzaj – Anderlecht/Man Utd
Mousa Dembele – Germinal Beerschot
Youri Tielemans – Anderlecht
Yannick Carrasco – Diegem Sport/Genk
Leander Dedoncker – Roeselare/Anderlecht
Nacer Chadli – JS THier-a-Liege/Standard Liege
Eden Hazard – Royal Stade Brainois/Lille
Thorgan Hazard – Royal Stade Brainois/Lens

Romelu Lukaku – Rupel Boom/Anderlecht
Dries Mertens – Anderlecht/Gent
Michy Batshuayi – RFC Evere/Standard Liege

More:

Belgium’s emergence as a major international force over the past ten years isn’t a coincidence. The ever-increasing low of talent from the country’s academies and development centres can be traced back to the late 90s, when a collective, nation-wide restructuring at grassroots level planted the first seeds of the Belgian football revolution.

The catalyst for major change came after the 1998 World Cup in France, when Belgium were eliminated at the Group Stages. Michel Sablon, the Belgian FA’s Technical Director at the time, developed the blueprint for how young footballers would be developed over the next 20 years in the country. His masterplan was inspired and the results incredible.

Belgian giants Anderlecht have been one of the biggest beneficiaries of Sablon’s development ideology. RSCA have 7 former academy graduates in Roberto Martinez World Cup squad and the club’s Neerpede Training Center has become a major European talent factory, supplying the rest of the continent with top class players. Developing players and selling them on is a process that the club are comfortable with.

In a 2014 interview with The Guardian, Anderlecht’s Director of Youth Jean Kindermans said: ““Our philosophy in Anderlecht is to be a trampoline for Europe. We only ask one thing: let us educate”.

The Numbers:

Anderlecht – 7
Genk – 4
Germinal Beerschot, Ajax – 3
Standard Liege – 2

Read More: Belgium’s Key Players Ahead of the 2018 World Cup

ENGLAND

England vs Nigeria World Cup 2018

(Name of player – Name of club that produced them)

Jack Butland – Birmingham City
Jordan Pickford – Sunderland
Nick Pope – Ipswich Town

Trent Alexander-Arnold – Liverpool
Gary Cahill – Aston Villa
Fabian Delph – Leeds United
Phil Jones – Blackburn Rovers
Harry Maguire – Sheffield United
Danny Rose – Leeds United
John Stones – Barnsley
Kieran Trippier – Man City
Kyle Walker – Sheffield United
Ashley Young – Watford

Dele Alli – Milton Keynes Dons
Eric Dier – Sporting CP
Jordan Henderson – Sunderland
Jesse Lingard – Man Utd
Ruben Loftus-Cheek – Chelsea

Harry Kane – Tottenham Hotspur
Marcus Rashford – Man Utd
Raheem Sterling – QPR
Jamie Vardy – Stocksbride Park Steels
Danny Welbeck – Man Utd

More:

Premier League clubs in England are quite often criticized for their reluctance to promote from within and while Gareth Southgate’s World Cup squad is among the youngest in the tournament, that criticism isn’t without its merits.

Only 8 of Southgate’s 23-man selection were produced by Premier League academies, with the other 15 developed in England’s lower leagues and beyond. With the Premiership awash with money, clubs are reluctant to give chances to their academy players, and instead choose to pack their squads out with foreign players in their prime.

The policy has resulted in a drain of talent in recent years with the likes of Chris Willock (Benfica), Kaylen Hinds (Wolfsburg), Danny Collinge (Stuttgart), Jadon Sancho (Borussia Dortmund), Mandela Egbo and Keanan Bennetts (Borussia Monchengladbach) all choosing to take their search for first team football to foreign leagues. Plenty more are reportedly eyeing a move to foreign shores too.

The demand for English youngsters suggests that the development system is doing plenty right. Of course, England are currently both U20 and U17 World champions, though finding a route to high level first team football for those world champions continues to be the biggest problem. The talent is clearly there, now it needs room to flourish.

Manchester United buck the English trend and are far and away the best producers of young talent in England. World Cup squad members Marcus Rashford, Jesse Lingard and Danny Welbeck all sharpened their skills as fledgling players at Carrington. In fact, there are 29 former United trainees currently playing at Premier League clubs. That’s almost double the number of the next most successful academies, Southampton and Tottenham (16 each).

Historically, United’s academy has always produced wonderful players. Former graduates include: Roger Byrne, Bill Foulkes, Jackie Blanchflower, Duncan Edwards, Billy Whelan, Nobby Stiles, Bobby Charlton, Johnny Giles, George Best, Norman Whiteside (the youngest player to play at a World Cup), Mark Hughes, Ryan Giggs, Gary Neville, David Beckham, Nicky Butt, Paul Scholes and Paul Pogba.

The Numbers:

Man Utd – 3
Leeds, Sheffield United, Sunderland – 2
Various – 1

Read More: England’s Lack of Depth in Midfield – Will it be a Problem in Russia?

PANAMA

Panama team photo

(Name of player – Name of club that produced them)

José Calderón – Chepo
Jaime Penedo – Estudiantes de Panama
Álex Rodríguez – Sporting San Miguelito

Felipe Baloy – Euro Kickers
Harold Cummings – Arabe Unido
Erick Davis – Arabe Unido
Fidel Escobar – San Francisco
Adolfo Machado – Allianza
Michael Amir Murillo – San Francisco
Luis Ovalle – Sporting San Miguelito
Román Torres – Chepo

Édgar Joel Bárcenas – Arabe Unido
Armando Cooper – Arabe Unido
Aníbal Godoy – Chepo
Gabriel Enrique Gómez – Sporting ’89
Valentín Pimentel – Chepo
Alberto Quintero Medina – Chorrillo
José Luis Rodríguez – Chorrillo

Abdiel Arroyo – Arabe Unido
Ismael Díaz – Tauro
Blas Pérez – Panama Viejo
Luis Tejada – Tauro
Gabriel Torres – Chepo

More: 

The crux of the Panamanian World Cup squad come from the academy at Liga Panameña de Fútbol club Arabe Unido. Based in the scenic city sea port of Colón on the country’s northern edge, Arabe Unido were founded as recently as 1994 by Arab immigrants, who gave the new sporting association their name.

Arabe Unido were successful pretty much from the word go, winning their first title four years after their inception and fifteen titles in all in the last twenty-four years. The club have forged a reputation for developing talent alongside their knack for winning silverware. 5 of Hernán Darío Gómez’ Panama World Cup squad came through the ranks at El Expreso Azul (The Blue Express).

3 of Gómez’ squad were also schooled by the youth coaches at Chepo FC, though Los Naranjas closed their doors in 2006 due to financial reasons. Founded in 1999, the club had been in existence just 17 years before it folded indefinitely.

The Numbers:

Arabe Unido – 5
Chepo – 3
Chorrillo, Sporting San Miguelito, Tauro – 2

Read More: Getting to know the Panama squad

TUNISIA

(Name of player – Name of club that produced them)

Aymen Mathlouthi – Club Africain
Farouk Ben Mustapha – Club Athletique Bizertin
Mouez Hassen – Stade Raphaelois

Hamdi Nagguez – Etoile du Sahel
Dylan Bronn – Cannes
Rami Bedoui – Etoile du Sahel
Yohan Benalouane – FC Tricastin/Saint-Etienne
Syam Ben Youssef – US Traminots Marseille/Bastia
Yassine Meriah – ES Metlaoui
Oussama Haddadi – Club Africain
Ali Maâloul – CS Sfaxien

Ellyes Skhiri – Montpellier
Mohamed Amine Ben Amor – Etoile du Sahel
Ghailene Chaalali – El Tunis
Ferjani Sassi – CS Sfaxien
Ahmed Khalil – JS Kairouan
Saîf-Eddine Khaoui – Tours
Anice Badri – Lille

Fakhreddine Ben Youssef – CS Sfaxien
Naïm Sliti – Marseille
Bassem Srarfi – Club Africain
Wahbi Khazri – JS AJaccio/Bastia
Saber Khalifa – Stade Gabesien

More:

With the strong historical links between the countries, it’s no surprise to see a sizeable French influence on Tunisia’s World Cup squad. No fewer than 9 of the players Nabil Maâloul is taking to Russia were housed at academies in France during the early parts of their respective careers.

The other 14 members of Tunisia’s World Cup squad were versed in the game from inside the country’s borders. Club Africain based in the capital Tunis have 3 former trainees playing in Russia this summer, as do CLP-1 rivals Etoile du Sahel. Both clubs are also represented well in the country’s various under-age teams.

Interestingly, recently crowned Tunisian champions Espérance Sportive de Tunis (who have now won the title for two seasons on the spin and seven in ten seasons in all), have just 1 former youth team player in Tunisia’s World Cup selection. They do have 2 current players in the 23-man roster however – both Ghailene Chaalali and Anice Badri play for the Mkachkha at present.

The Numbers:

Club Africain, Etoile du Sahel – 3
Bastia, CS Sfaxien – 2
Various – 1

Read More: World Cup Group G Analysis: England and Belgium Battle it Out

Follow Free Super Tips on Twitter to stay up to date with our daily tips and predictions or browse more football content on our website:

Related Articles