New York City vs Toronto FC Predictions

• New York City have taken 21 of their 28 points at home.
• The hosts have won seven of their ten league games at The Yankee Stadium

Home advantage to play a part in New York

New York City are a short price to take all three points at the Yankee Stadium on Thursday night, but those odds are still worth taking against an underperforming Toronto FC side that haven’t beaten them in over two years.

The Pigeons have won each of their five meetings with the Canadian side since that 2023 loss, and they have made the Yankee Stadium something of a fortress so far this season, picking up 21 of their 28 MLS points in front of their own fans.

They have won seven of their ten outings here, and Toronto FC’s recent resurgence on their travels is less impressive than it first appears. They have beaten CF Montreal and Real Salt Lake away from home, but those two sides have only picked up 16 points at home between them in 2025, and prior to that The Reds had drawn two and lost three of their five trips away.